Convention Proposal: Unknown Trash Finesse about hanabi.github.io

[Zamiell]

I don't think this needs to be an explicit convention. If Alice sees that the natural fix clue is to re-clue number 1, then yellow will cause Finesse Position to be blind-played as a Known Bluff.

[aliblong]

Is there any advantage to this being play slot 1 rather than ejection/discharge for consistency's sake?

Also, the second y1 in Bob's original hand is irrelevant, right? And you're talking about a non-multicolor variant.

[Romain672]

Personnally I learn to answer by slot 1 if it's logical. Or slot 2 if slot 1 isn't logical.
It's consistency with that way of thinking.

[Dr-Kakashi]

Known bluffs are for cards that are "good touched." If that's the case, then if trash is picked up it should be a discharge, due to the Unknown Trash Discharge Convention?

[Zamiell]

It does not make sense for Bob to have the yellow 2, yellow 3, yellow 4, or yellow 5 (as the brand new card introduced). If it was any of these cards, then Alice would not blind-play - she would wait for Bob to play the yellow 1 first, and then try to blind-play something.

Thus, since Alice blind-played, the brand new yellow card introduced must be a yellow 1.

[Dr-Kakashi]

Gotcha! Known bluff it is then

[Zamiell]

/deny

[conventions-bot]

The consensus of the group appears to be to not integrate this proposal. This issue will now be closed; feel free to continue to comment on the issue if you feel that the discussion was ended prematurely.

(For more information on how consensus is determined, please read the Convention Changes document.)