coblox / 2019-genesis-workshop Goto Github PK

Lessons from the workshop:

• It works!
• comit-i is easy to use
• It is hard to create a dev Ethereum network with parity
• It is easy to create a regtest Bitcoin network with bitcoind
• bitcoind commandline is not that user friendly but ok
  • Except when the amount in comit-i is satoshi and bitcoind wants bitcoins: see comit-network/comit-i#95
• Links works but people are surprised that other can change the rates in link
  • Follow-up on link-id discussion so that for a given link-id bobtimus/comit-i reject a swap if details are different?
• It gets confusing when there is a lot of swap
  • To know what swap is from whom: does it matter?
  • To know what swap is buy/sell: see comit-network/comit-i#97
• Rust developers may not have nightly. see comit-network/comit-rs#1047
• Despite node setup, Rust compilation was the most challenging
• People prefer BTC/Ether to Sat/Wei: see comit-network/comit-i#95
• Link is too long
• Alpha/Beta wording is confusing, especially when accepting/declining a swap. Is comit-network/comit-i#97 enough?
• Fund/Refund/Redeem terms are confusing, proposed terms are Send/Cancel/Receive
• People loved hands on format -> Ok refund makes sense. but Lock makes more sense than Fund
• remove web+comit from link
• Make it a game/competition next time
• Do a wrap-up with open questions next time
• Implement auto-refresh or websocket