Secp256k1Point bincode deserialization error about curv

[omershlo]

Secp256k1 is a struct with a string for the purpose of the point and the coordinates taken from secp256k1 library. Default Serde will not work here and therefore we implemented Deserialize / Serialize ourselves: https://github.com/KZen-networks/curv/blob/master/src/elliptic/curves/secp256_k1.rs#L534
please use this instead.

[kigawas]

Why can't I use bincode's serialize_struct?

https://github.com/servo/bincode/blob/master/src/ser/mod.rs#L190

[omershlo]

I don't know :(

[djc]

That's what this is intended to solve. However, testing it is painful at the moment because of how your crates use Git tags for versioning rather than having an actual crate registry (which would allow use of semver).

[omershlo]

Can you elaborate more on that point?
Are you saying that uploading the libraries to crates.io would have make more sense in some sense ?

[djc]

Yes, uploading them to crates.io would definitely make things easier. However, I suppose at least in the case of curv and rust-paillier there are already crates on there. Maybe @mortendahl @mcornejo @kali would allow you to publish to crates.io/crates/paillier? curv is currently squatted on crates.io so it might have to be renamed somehow.

[omershlo]

I am not religious about naming. The only issue that stops us from uploading everything is Curv dependency on a specific commit of Zcash library to support the curve Jubjub. All the other libraries are dependent on Curv so they are stuck as well.

[omershlo]

We uploaded https://crates.io/crates/emerald-city/0.2.0 just because we removed the Zcash dependency

[djc]

Having to depend on a particular commit is in itself a bit suspicious (same with the rust-gmp fork). Would be nice to work with the zcash folks to see if some of their crates could get onto crates.io in a version that you can consume.

As it is, if you make a curv change you'll also have to immediately retag rust-paillier and zk-paillier again to prevent duplicates in downstream dependency graphs, so that sucks a bit. Maybe a custom registry could be a decent option? Either with https://blog.mgattozzi.dev/turning-github-into-your-own-registry/ or using Cloudsmith.

[mortendahl]

Maybe @mortendahl @mcornejo @kali would allow you to publish to crates.io/crates/paillier?

If you guys are still using rust-paillier then I'll make it a priority to get any existing and new PRs merged and published.