Support jack of all trades (i.e. different base value for untrained skills) about twodsix-foundryvtt

[xdy]

This might be best handled as a Trait that changes the 'minimum skill level' on the character (i.e. the skill level a new skill gets added at.)
That is, use the same item type as racial traits etc, which haven't been added yet.

[xdy]

Jack of All Trades isn't particularly well supported.
One setting is per-client (i.e. each logged in user can set it), "The value that is used for untrained skills.", Change this to match the character's level of the 'Jack of All Trades' (JOAT) skill. If you have JOAT 1, set the value to -2, etc.
As long as each player only has one character this works fairly well.
Of course, it fails horribly if a player has several characters with different levels of Jack of all trades. (As there is only a setting per player rather than per character).

This setting needs to be removed and a proper solution implemented.

[jonepatr]

Would a solution be to just have a permanent skill as part of the character sheet for jack of all trades, which then in turn modifies all untrained skill rolls?

[xdy]

My thought on this was to add a new item type 'trait', that would have 'key','name','level','description' to start with. Then add them to the character sheet (probably a new tab, possibly a new list below skills).
Then the code that currently sets the unskilled penalty would check for the 'JOAT' trait, check it's level, and set the penalty.

The point of doing it via traits is traits would also be used to support all other 'this character breaks a particular rule' situations, like races, etc. And to handle things like this: https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/262129/Cepheus-Light-Traits
In the long run, traits would most likely have Active Effects (like, 'if you have Claws, your Unarmed attack does +1d6', or whatever.)

[xdy]

Fixed by #306

[jonepatr]

This issue should be closed, right?

[xdy]

Yep!