tc39 / proposal-intl-localematcher

Proposal for Intl.LocaleMatcher

Intl.LocaleMatcher

Motivation

i18n-supported websites often get a list of preferred locales via Accept-Language header or navigator.languages. They then try to determine the best available locale based on the set of locales that they support (and have translations for).

This operation currently exists within ECMA-402 but is only available as an abstract operation. Surfacing this functionality as a top level API would improve locale negotiation correctness and developer productivity as sites will be able to reliably handle not only matching, but also aliases, fallbacks and such.

Use cases

1. Given a set of locales an application has translations for and the set of locales a user requests, find the best matching locales.
2. JS runtimes (& polyfills) are not required to guarantee supporting all locales. Given a set of locales it supports and what the user requests, find the best matching locales.
3. An application can also provide different "tones" of the same locales (e.g casual, formal), utilizing -x- private tag. Given a set of locales with extensions and what the user preference might be, find the best matching locales.

Status

Stage 1

Ponyfill: https://formatjs.io/docs/polyfills/intl-localematcher

Champion

• Long Ho (@longlho)

API

interface Options {
    algorithm: 'lookup' | 'best fit'
}

Intl.LocaleMatcher.match(
    requestedLocales: string[],
    availableLocales: string[],
    defaultLocale: string,
    options?: Options
): string

Options

1. lookup would continue to be the existing LookupMatcher implementation within ECMA-402.
2. best fit would be implementation-dependent.

Examples

Intl.LocaleMatcher.match(["fr-XX", "en"], ["fr", "en"], "en"); // 'fr'

Prior Arts

@hapi/accept

This is the core of hapijs header parsing with quality preferences. This however does a naive hierarchy with exact matches only. For example:

Accept.language("en;q=0.7, fr-XX;q=0.8", ["fr", "en"]); // language === "en"

which would not be accurate.

koa

Similarly, Koa's request.acceptsLanguages follow similar exact match algorithm.

UTS35 LanguageMatching

This details a more sophisticated locale negotiation algorithm that is more accurate than hapi/koa

RFC4647 Section 3.4

This is the lookup algorithm in ECMA-402.

cldrjs's lookup implementation

Similar to UTS35 LanguageMatching.

References

• tc39/ecma402#513
• tc39/ecma402#46
• vercel/next.js#18676