pwa-police / pwa-bugs

🚔 List of PWA Bugs and workarounds

PWA Bugs

This is a general repo for PWA bugs in all browsers, likely most of them will be about iOS (Web.app)

• Android WebView
  • Problem: different User Agent for different request
• Firefox, Android
  • Problem: Cross-origin redirects for <img /> tag cause Firefox to open Custom Tab browser
• iOS Safari
  • Problem: in iOS 12 cache in Cache Storage magically disappears
  • Problem: Cookie/Login isn't shared between Safari and standalone mode
  • Problem: Cross domain authorization in standalone mode doesn't work
  • Problem: Sometimes PWA is added in normal mode and not standalone mode
  • Problem: PWA is added without a splashscreen
  • Problem: Navigation to a website has infinite loading
  • Problem: Push Notifications are not supported
• Android
  • Problem: No migration on new Android phone

Android WebView

Problem: different User Agent for different request

In some browsers with Android WebView, e.g. Opera Mini or UC Browser (Mini?), browser sends different User Agent strings for different request.

To be precise, when ServiceWorker is used and in 'fetch' listener you do e.respondWith(fetch(e.request)) for navigation requests, it send original WebView User Agent. But for all subsequent requests, it send custom User Agent which was set by the browser's code.

Doing or not doing e.respondWith(fetch(e.request)) for non-navigation requests doesn't change anything. The only solution is to stop handling navigation requests in ServiceWorker (or 'fetch' event at all).

Firefox, Android

Problem: Cross-origin redirects for <img /> tag cause Firefox to open Custom Tab browser

Bug Report: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1515789

Status: Fix will be shipped in FF67

Cross-origin redirects for <img /> tag cause Firefox to open Custom Tab browser, just like if Cross Origin navigation happen.

So for example if you have bunch of images request this way on a page, e.g. 100 image, Firefox will open 100 Custom Tabs for your PWA.

iOS Safari

Web App Manfest and ServiceWorker API are supported on iOS since 11.3.
Reference: https://twitter.com/rmondello/status/956256845311590400

Problem: in iOS 12 cache in Cache Storage magically disappears

WebKit Bug: https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=190269

Solution:

This bug makes Cache Storage persist only until user closes Safari (or it's unloaded from memory). Basically, the cache is some temporary place and is erased when Safari is closed. There is really no workaround around this. It causes this situation.

• User visits a website
• ServiceWorker caches everything
• User closes Safari
• User visits a website again while offline
• Nothing loads

It also affects websites in standalone mode. This bug also prevents Safari from sharing the cache between standalone mode and normal Safari mode.

Problem: Cookie/Login isn't shared between Safari and standalone mode

Problem is in all iOS version.

Solution:

At the time of writing (iOS 12.0.1), there is only couple version of Safari where the workaround works.

The workaround is to transfer a session through Cache Storage API, which has shared cache in some Safari versions.
Approximately how the workaround works:

• User visits a website
• User opens the Share Popup to add website to the homescreen
• When popup opens, Safari sends destination='manifeset' request to the server
• ServiceWorker intercepts the requests and send another to the server to generate temporary token
• ServiceWorker stores the token in special cache in Cache Storage API
• User taps "Add to Homescreen"
• User opens website from the homescreen
• ServiceWorker intercepts the opening and send another request to the server with the saved token
• Server checks the token and authorizes the user
• ServiceWorker allows navigation to finish
• User is automatically authorized in standalone mode

Now gotchas.

It works only in iOS 11.4.1 though. It's broken in iOS 12 and iOS 12.0.1, but supposed to be fixed in the next version. WebKit Bug for iOS 12: https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=190269

Even though ServiceWorker was introduces in iOS 11.3, it's unknown if anything prior 11.4.1 can support this. It either just doesn't work in iOS Emulator at all or doesn't work prioer 11.4.1 (latest 11 emulator version is 11.4.0).

Tested on real devices with these versions:

• 11.4.1 -- works
• 12.0.0 -- doesn't work
• 12.0.1 -- doesn't work

Problem: Cross domain authorization in standalone mode doesn't work

This issue happens since 11.3 when Web App Manifest is used.
iOS requires scope property in Web App Manifest to determine which URLs allowed to be opened in standalone mode and which are not. When user website navigates to any URL outside of the scope (this includes any URL with different domain) -- it drops the navigation from standalone mode and opens it in Safari. This makes cross-domain authorization impossible.

Solution:

Use the iframe.

Let's suppose there is a foo.com website and its login is on login.foo.com
Here is approximately how this can be solved:

• Authorization request is sent to foo.com
• ServiceWorker intercepts this request and cloned request to the server, with redirect: 'manual'
• ServiceWorker tells the page to create <iframe> and request a fake url
• ServiceWorker responds to the <iframe> fake url request with the response from syntetic request from the step 2
• <iframe> handles the response. The response must have a redirect
• ServiceWorker intercepts the redirect from <iframe> and send another cloned request with redirect: 'manual'
• If type of the response is basic, the send the response to original authorization from the step 1
• If type of the response is opaqueredirect, repeat the steps from step 3

Problem: Sometimes PWA is added in normal mode and not standalone mode

(like there is no manifest at all)

Reference: https://twitter.com/nekrtemplar/status/1040282198044291072

Safari fetches the manifest only when user is about to add the website to homescreen. To be preceice, manifest is fetched exactly when Share Popup is opened.

So if user performs all the steps very fast: 1) Open popup; 2) Tap "Add to Home Screen"; 3) Tap "Add" on the adding popup; Then in some cases the manifest might be fetched yet, so website will be added like there is no manifest.

Solution:

Thankfully, when Safari fetches the manifest, that request goes to the ServiceWorker with request.destination being manifest, as per spec. This means that it's possible to intercept such request and return manifest contents from the cache. So the solution would be to precache the manifest on ServiceWorker install and serve it to the browser from the cache.

Problem: PWA is added without a splashscreen

Even if all correct splashscreen elements are added to the page, after adding the website to the home screen, it may not have the splashscreen.

Solution:

When website is added only with Web App Manifest, Safari doesn't take splashscreen elements into the account. The solution would be adding <meta name="apple-mobile-web-app-capable" content="yes"> element to the page alongside with the manifest.

Note: It might be better adding apple-mobile-web-app-capable dynamically and only when in browser mode. When in standalone mode, it may affects URLs behavior since Web App Manifest installed PWA and apple-mobile-web-app-capable installed PWA have different URL behavior on iOS.

Problem: Navigation to a website has infinite loading

If update of a ServiceWorker happens when there is a page navigation in-flight and ServiceWorker install event resolves sooner than the navigation page is finished loading, then Safari kills old ServiceWorker immediately even without calling self.skipWaiting() and that break loading on the page and hence it never loads.

Solution:

Check for navigation requests when install event happens and do not resolve the promise if there are any. When page loads, send message to the installing ServiceWorker that it may try again to resolve the installation promise (check again for navigation request, repeat all the steps until no navigation requests, then resolve the promise).

Problem: Push Notifications are not supported

Both Push subscription (Push API) and displaying notifications (Notifications API) are not supported in iOS. There is no pushManager in ServiceWorker registration object - so don't forget to do a feature detection in your code.

Solution:

There is no good workaround/polyfill as this feature fully depends on the 3rd party Messaging Service infrastructure (Apple Push Notifications Service in that case) which is not supporting the standartized (VAPID, Push API, Notifications API) way to subscribe for/receive/display notifications. There are no signals from Apple/Safari about this feature is under consideration/development. There is a Twitter thread with discussing the possible solution to have a kind of notifications on iOS: https://twitter.com/webmaxru/status/1034882612978966528. Some outcomes:

• For Safari on Mac you can set up Push notifications using a proprietary implementation: https://developer.apple.com/notifications/safari-push-notifications/
• The working (but cumbersome) solution is to wrap your PWA app into a native iOS one using, for example, Cordova.
• The closest (but still not a "real") pure web solution is to set up a PassBook that can receive push. But this way your notifications are disconnected from the app itself.

Android

Problem: No migration on new Android phone

When migrating to another Android device all native apps are moved to the new one but none of the PWAs. On the new device for the PWAs there where just empty icons and if clicked on them you could search for the PWA in the Play Store :( Even the top PWAs like Twitter Lite have this problem.

pwa-bugs's Issues

Problem with iOS Splashscreen

The solution in the doc doesn't seem complete. This article with examples shows how to do it properly.

Sorry, right now don't have time to PR. Maybe someone do it faster than me

iOS Infinite Loading

Is there any working example to handle the Infinite Loading on iOS ?

I am trying to follow the proposed solution but without success.

iOs doen't allow to shut down the app

The problem is decribed in the article
After iOs 12.2:

PWAs have a new lifecycle and on most normal situations, the state of your app will be saved and restored between sessions, but there is no way to kill the PWA and restart it from scratch.

That is actually quite a nasty problem when you need to unload the app and to launch fresh one again. You just can't -)

There is not very consistent workaround: exit the app, and try to load some other "PWA" or even just some site in Safari. Often it leads to unloading target "PWA" from memory. Though I believe it depends on available resources.

Add problem and solution with PWA iOS icon

iOS PWA does't support icons from manifest.json. The solution is to add link apple-touch-icon with different sizes.

Example:
<link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href="apple-touch-icon.png">

iOS 12 and "mailto:"

On iOS 12 when PWA is in "standalone" mode (installed) there is no way to correctly handle the "mailto:" link

<a href="mailto:[email protected]">test[dot]com</a>
<a href="mailto:[email protected]" target="_blank">test[dot]com</a<

The only workaround found is to add a click event handler similar to:

()=>{
    window.location.href = "mailto:[email protected]?subject=" + emailSubject + "&body=" + emailBody
    return
}

On iOS 13 the standard usage works correctly.

iOS Keyboard not appearing

Bluetooth and Wifi is off but it still doesn't appear. If I switch to light mode it works.

Cache Storage persist only until user closes Safari

Is there still no workaround for this issue in iOS 12.1?

"Problem: in iOS 12 cache in Cache Storage magically disappears"

or

“Safari and the home screen shortcut share the same Service Worker registration (but not the instance) and the cached files. Safari View Controller (such as the In-App Browser within Twitter) supports Service Workers and the cache but it seems it’s deleting all the data after the session is closed.”

:_(

IOS input type file camera [12.2]

Hi, I found an error with input type file with caputre="camera"
Steps to reprodue:
open app,
click input,
do not create photo and close app.
Open app again
You cannot use input again
It started with ios 12.2 update (saving state of app), didn't notice it on android.