stompest.async will be unusable on python 3.7+ about stompest

[sergey-sobolev]

I've renamed stompest.async to stompest.twisted as it was proposed, also had to update activemq user credentials for unit tests as it didn't work with the default empty user/pass.

I've checked the unit tests - all stompest.twisted tests have passed, but one test in stompest.core fails (test_5_integration_stomp_1_1_heartbeat).
https://github.com/sergey-sobolev/stompest/tree/develop

Anybody willing to test?

[nikipore]

Thank you. That's a breaking change indeed.

Does anyone have a suggestion for an alternative to the pair of names sync/async?

[arjunv]

thanks @cdunklau for reporting on behalf. i ended up using the sync version instead :(

[arjunv]

@nikipore you intend to port the package to support python async? in that case you could follow the convention followed by similar async packages with aiostomp.

[nikipore]

@arjunv: I am no longer using stompest actively, because I have moved on inside the enterprise —
who still uses stompest in production but has no-one with both the skill and time to maintain it — to a non-coding strategic/leadership position. Therefore, it is more of a hobby, and I have to rebuild my testing and building environment from scratch every few months which rather sucks.

A few random thoughts:

0. I still do accept (and test) pull requests and bugfixes, but the Python 3 port was my last big effort for stompest.
1. I believe that the (half-complete) SSL/TLS capability is the most urgent improvement because I see stompest pretty much feature complete and stable up to Python 3.6; it displays a very low rate of found bugs indeed.
2. For Python 3.7, the stompest.async package should be renamed stompest.twisted. If someone creates a pull request, I'll test it and rename the PyPI package accordingly.
3. A port to asyncio would make a lot of sense. If someone creates a pull request, I'll test it and create a new PyPI package.
4. If someone wants to take over the project, please let me know. I would actively consult as an éminence grise.

[cdunklau]

@arjunv it looks like you misunderstood this bug report. In case that's true, I'll be explicit:
while it appears that stompest.async should work on versions of Python 3 that Twisted supports (3.3 - 3.6), the problem I reported is that it will just not work on 3.7+ due to the PEP 492-required change.

[arjunv]

@cdunklau Actually you cannot import the package from within an async function, as I had attempted to do, which had caused the bug in my code, in the first place. This would be true for python > 3.5 and not just 3.7+. (Of course you can globally import, but I was using a custom module to install and import external packages in runtime [for a client who can't even be bothered with installing packages], which forced me to do import within an async function).

Python 3.6.4 (default, Dec 23 2017, 19:07:07) 
>>> async def function():
...     from stompest.async import Stomp
  File "<stdin>", line 2
    from stompest.async import Stomp
                      ^
SyntaxError: invalid syntax

[nitrag]

Bump, has any managed to rewrite this yet? Py3.7 is installed by default now.

[zaqk]

Bump, it has been a while. I would hate to have to use an entirely differently library due to a naming issue like this.

[nikipore]

#54 (comment)