alias rewriter: unclear how to specify attributes? about odata-query

[srepmub]

to try and be more precise, this seems to more about how to support the following 'any' construct:

$filter=Attributes/OData.CSC.StringAttribute/any(att:att/Name eq 'productType' and att/OData.CSC.StringAttribute/Value eq 'AUX_ECMWFD')

where the actual attributes should be mapped to individual database fields.. so in this case it should just work like:

$filter=productType eq 'AUX_ECMWFD'

[srepmub]

I see there is some level of support for 'any', but when feeding above filter an exception is raised:

(grammar.py, def error)
raise exceptions.TokenizingException(text)
..
NameError: name 'text' is not defined

I guess any python linter would have caught this.. :P

[srepmub]

(problem seems to be the dots, as in OData.CSC.StringAttribute)

[srepmub]

after a removing the dots, the 'any' call is transformed into a nice ast, which I can probably use a rewriter on.. so perhaps the dots are the only issue here.

[srepmub]

from looking at the odata ABNF, the dots are used to indicate 'namespaces'. is there any plan to support these, at least at the ast level?

[OliverHofkens]

Hey there, glad to hear that the library is (mostly) doing its job for you!
I haven't used OData namespaces yet, but implementing this in the AST sounds like a pretty easy win.
I'm gonna try to reserve some time next friday to try an implementation.

As for the alias rewriter, I agree that the docs are a bit sparse and I'd need to add some examples. In theory it can map any OData construct to something else, but I've personally only used it for simplifying nested relationships, e.g.:
author -> blogpost/author/name.
I'd be happy to look at your case once namespaces are implemented. If the alias rewriter doesn't suffice, a new rewriter that specifically handles OData attributes and namespaces could be an option!

[srepmub]

thanks! :) yeah, just having the namespaces in the AST would be great. the rewriting part was actually quite easy once I looked better at the existing example.. so that seems fine. also not sure if a generic rewriter would be useful or even possible, as I may be the only one with this particular problem?

[srepmub]

hello oliver,

any updates on namespace support in the AST..? =)

[OliverHofkens]

I tried adding namespaces in a feature branch about two weeks ago, and it turned out to be harder than I expected (grammar conflicts are a nightmare). Maybe I was too set on the idea that the namespaces should've been integrated as grammar rules. Thinking about it now it would be easier to just allow dots in Identifier nodes, and then post-process that with properties. E.g. OData.CSC.StringAttribute would simply become Identifier('OData.CSC.StringAttribute'), and we can split that in namespace and attribute later.

I'm definitely still periodically working on this, but I can't really give a proper timeline when this will be finished.

[srepmub]

thanks for having a look, and the feedback! we are not blocking on this, but it would be a nice improvement of course.

[OliverHofkens]

Phew, finally had some time to work on this!
Release 0.5.x now supports parsing namespaces, storing them in the Identifier nodes of the AST.
Nothing is currently done with these namespaces, but at least the parser shouldn't crash.

Note that release 0.5 also includes full typing support, so keep that in mind if you use Mypy and upgrade.

I'm keeping this ticket open to discuss more complete namespace support in the future!

[srepmub]

yeah, thanks! I tried the new version, and it doesn't crash anymore for us, so I removed the regular-expression hack to manually strip namespaces. I'm still wondering though, why I don't see the 'OData.CSC' namespace for this filter:

Attributes/OData.CSC.StringAttribute/any(att:att/Name eq 'processingCenter' and att/OData.CSC.StringAttribute/Value eq 'CLS-Brest')

reflected in the resulting AST:

CollectionLambda(owner=Attribute(owner=Identifier(name='Attributes', namespace=()), attr='StringAttribute'), operator=Any(), lambda_=Lambda(identifier=Identifier(name='att', namespace=()), expression=BoolOp(op=And(), left=Compare(comparator=Eq(), left=Attribute(owner=Identifier(name='att', namespace=()), attr='Name'), right=String(val='processingCenter')), right=Compare(comparator=Eq(), left=Attribute(owner=Attribute(owner=Identifier(name='att', namespace=()), attr='StringAttribute'), attr='Value'), right=String(val='CLS-Brest')))))

I would expect the namespace to appear where it now says "attr='StringAttribute'"..? so eg by changing attr into an Identifier node..?

[OliverHofkens]

Ah damn, that's an oversight on my part. I didn't think about namespaces appearing in Attributes...
Thanks for reporting back in any case! I think this should be a pretty quick fix, I'll have a look at this soon.

And glad that it doesn't crash anymore in the first place 😅