How to read a dicom file from network stream about fo-dicom

[gofal]

Agree, unseekable streams are already implemented in development branch. Could you verify, when using the latest development-code, that opening the file from networkstream actually works?

[cocosip]

gree, unseekable streams are already implemented in development branch. Could you verify, when using the latest development-code, that opening the file from networkstream actually works?

I use HttpClient.GetStreamAsync(url) to get the stream, but the stream not support get the length。So the stream returned by the GetStreamAsync method cannot be used directly to open a DICOM file。

[gofal]

Ah ja, the UnseekableStreamByteSource assumes, that seeking is not supported. But this stream not even supports the Length property, which is even worse.
The quick fix is to download into a memorystream and then to parse using fo-dicom. The long fix, is to implement another version of ByteSource that uses streams without using Length. But to tell you the truth, this class internallly will have no other chance than to just download the data piecewise, buffer it into a memorystream and then do the parsing from that memorystream. That is also how UnseekableStreamByteSource is doing it.
So it will not be faster or less memory consuming because in both ways it has to download all the data, and the parsing will only be finished when all the data is ready downloaded. It will mainly be syntactic sugar because it saves you 1 line of code and newbie users are not surprised about a NotSupportedException when opening a DicomFile from a HttpResponseStream.