Redis URL improvement about send

[timvisee]

I've now added all desired variables: REDIS_{HOST,PORT,USER,PASSWORD,DB}.

I've released this as part of v3.4.11.

It should be available when this pipeline succeeds: https://gitlab.com/timvisee/send/-/pipelines/305718044

[skorokithakis]

Separate variables are good too, as long as I can specify all of them (host/port/username/pw/db).

[timvisee]

You can also set the port and password through a separate variable:

send/server/config.js

Lines 62 to 76 in 385ac59

	redis_host: {
	format: String,
	default: 'localhost',
	env: 'REDIS_HOST'
	},
	redis_port: {
	format: Number,
	default: 6379,
	env: 'REDIS_PORT'
	},
	redis_password: {
	format: String,
	default: '',
	env: 'REDIS_PASSWORD'
	},

But I agree that supporting the more conventional URL would be better.

[skorokithakis]

Oh, that's good enough, thanks! I'm trying to set up Send using Compose at the moment, and this seems adequate.

I don't know if you'd be interested to add support, but I wrote a tool for easier deployment of apps such as this one. It's still early, but it's quite useful to me, at least: https://pypi.org/project/docker-harbormaster/

[timvisee]

Oh, that's good enough, thanks!

Great. I'll leave it open as tracking issue for Redis URL support to be implemented.

I don't know if you'd be interested to add support, but I wrote a tool for easier deployment of apps such as this one. It's still early, but it's quite useful to me, at least: https://pypi.org/project/docker-harbormaster/

Sounds cool. What would 'adding support' mean, having to provide a compose file?

You might find this template useful: https://github.com/timvisee/send-docker-compose

[skorokithakis]

Yes, it's just providing a compose file with the {{ HM_DATA_DIR }}/my_data:/some_data_dir volumes defined.

Then you could tell people to just add:

repositories:
  timvisee-send:
    url: https://github.com/timvisee/send.git

to their config and it would be automatically spun up. It's probably too early for me to push it very hard, I was just wondering whether something like this would be interesting to app developers.

[pirate]

I added more documentation to the Docker / Docker Compose configs for the REDIS_HOST, REDIS_PORT, and REDIS_PASSWORD options here:

• #34
• timvisee/send-docker-compose#4

Personally I don't think Redis URL support is worth adding, given these options are already present. But I don't have strong opinions either way as long as separate vars stay supported.

imo a higher priority task is to add a REDIS_DB option to select which Redis DB to use e.g. 0, 1, etc. (ability to specify DB no. would also be required to support Redis URLs anyway).

[timvisee]

I wonder what the more conventional approach would be?

I've mostly seen separate variables, but maybe Redis URLs are used elsewhere. I'd be happy with both.