Black screen on TTY1 after booting only about os

[JGG-Apps]

To ensure all my test and configuration was done properly. I decided to download GroovyArcade 2022.01 (previous version) and install it on the same hardware.

I confirm everything is working fine, no issue with 2022.01.

[substring]

Hi,

Can you share details about your configuration ? What GPU, if you have an onboard GPU, etc...
The only change between the 2 OS releases is that 2022.21 uses KMS by default, and SFML is not working well yet with multiple GPUs

[JGG-Apps]

Hi,

My hardware configuration:

Lenovo M72e (PN: 4004) (Intel i3 CPU, Intel HD graphics, Yes onboard GPU)

On this hardware (tested more 1 PC that have the same hardware):
2022.01 with 15 khz VGA-1 = Work fine !
2022.10 with 15 khz = Not work properly (toggle with TTY2 kill process can fix the issue)
2022.10 with 15 khz Intel/nVidia = Not work properly (toggle with TTY2 kill process can fix the issue)
2022.10 with LCD = Not work properly (toggle with TTY2 kill process can fix the issue)

NOTE: Testing this hardware with Debian 9/10/11/12, Ubuntu 18/20, Kali, ParrotOS, Windows, etc. is always working fine

[substring]

My guess is that you need X11 instead of KMS. I can't say I encourage Intel or Nvidia GPUs, they give erratic results. Try switching to X11 in gasetup > setup > video setup > X/KMS then just reboot

[JGG-Apps]

Hi, thank you for your very fast answer !!! Yes' i can understand to don't encourage Intel/nVidia, but the actual reality on the market i: If you want to use a commercial, robust hardware and in this case tiny format like Lenovo, HP, Intel NUC to easly insert them in a machine (embedded concept)... where these tiny machine don't have expansion slots, you are juste facing using Intel GPU ;)

During this, I decided to test on an older machine I had: Lenovo M58 tower with nVidia card in PCIe slot.

2022.10 is working fine in 15khz mode !!!

---

Then I think your idea about X11 vs KMS should be something I need to test. I will confirm you ASAP.

Finally, I have a suggestion to improve GroovyArcade adoption. Actually, it don't have an official website, just the project on GitHub. It may have at least a link to an official web page where you could list "compatible hardware" certified and tested.

[substring]

You mean https://gitlab.com/groovyarcade/support/-/wikis/2-Pre-Requisites-and-Installation/2.1-Hardware-Suggestions-General ?

Most of everything happens on Discord, you'll find a link on the wiki

But what I should do is at least add README to that project, yeah

But there are some interesting NUC size PCs with Ryzen : check Lenovo m715q or HP Elitedesk mini 800 G4

[JGG-Apps]

Oh tanks, Your GitLab WIKI is interesting !!!

For this issue. Weird symptoms...

First, I switched to X11. Since I selected X11, on reboot I just get the GroovyArcade logo at boot with progress bar 100% and still there (not freezed, I can see the logo fade in/out)... If I wait 5-10 minutes the logo still there.

Where it start to be weird:
If I press ESC to see the booting steps, the result is never the same... It could be every step like:
Starting Samba SMB Daemon...
or
[OK] Finished Initializes Pacman keyring

but... If I press again ESC, I get the gasetup telling "Exit Setup Menu ?"

It's like what I get from the first ESC is just a kind of cache.

If I answer "No" to exit setup, return to main menu, select "Start Frond End", MAME Attreact Plus is shown !

---

Aftert that, if I decide to make a clean POWER OFF from gasetup, relaunch the PC, I still getting the same issue.

• I need to wait 2 min least
• I press ESC, the kernel boot process is shown
• I press ESC once again, the gasetup tell me to exit, I say no and I return to main menu to start the Front-End.
• I can use MAME !

---

Knowing that, I decided to came back with KMS to test same procedure... No luck. I got the initial issue where I have a full black screen with KMS. ESC key not work.

---

Then,

Yes X11 respond in another manner... I can manually tweak but something still hanging somewhere and not giving an expected result.

In bith case, KMS or X11 something happen where video is not properly displayed "on normal boot process only". If I force (break, kill, relaunch, etc.) the KMS or X11 is displaying the MAME console ?!?

[JGG-Apps]

I generated a log: https://transfer.sh/09Y6pm/ga-support.tar.zst

[substring]

Make sure you've updated GA, using X11 required some trickery that was fixed after the release of the ISO

[JGG-Apps]

Yep, pacman -Syu.... and some problems due tu an expired certificate on 2022-12-01 needs a bypass in pacman.conf. But after that, it's not better. Obtenir Outlook pour Android<https://aka.ms/AAb9ysg>

…

________________________________ From: Subs ***@***.***> Sent: Friday, December 16, 2022 3:03:47 AM To: substring/os ***@***.***> Cc: JGG-Apps ***@***.***>; Author ***@***.***> Subject: Re: [substring/os] Black screen on TTY1 after booting only (Issue #23) Make sure you've updated GA, using X11 required some trickery that was fixed after the release of the ISO — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#23 (comment)>, or unsubscribe<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ATOEQ7GDOUOUOY5AE3GJCI3WNQO6HANCNFSM6AAAAAAS7FMV2Y>. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[substring]

you don't bypass anything, you update first archlinux-keyring, then the full OS.

what happens when you start /opt/galauncher/startfe.sh ?

[JGG-Apps]

No... the certificate I talk was not renewd by the author. We need to ignore the signature for the moment :( archlinux-keyring update not fix... another forums on the Internet talk about this issue for ArchLinux. Since the initial request, If I kill startfe.sh manually from TTY2, then try to launch startfe.sh manually, it always work fine. Obtenir Outlook pour Android<https://aka.ms/AAb9ysg>

…

________________________________ From: Subs ***@***.***> Sent: Friday, December 16, 2022 8:22:55 AM To: substring/os ***@***.***> Cc: JGG-Apps ***@***.***>; Author ***@***.***> Subject: Re: [substring/os] Black screen on TTY1 after booting only (Issue #23) you don't bypass anything, you update first archlinux-keyring, then the full OS. what happens when you start /opt/galauncher/startfe.sh ? — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#23 (comment)>, or unsubscribe<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ATOEQ7FLAUC4SL2VDBKQWY3WNRUK7ANCNFSM6AAAAAAS7FMV2Y>. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[substring]

What happens when you mannually launch startfe.sh when X is set as the video backend ? do you get any error ?

By the way, it's necessary to rollback mesa, 22.3.x broke everything. Just sudo pacman -U --noconfirm https://archive.archlinux.org/packages/m/mesa/mesa-22.2.4-1-x86_64.pkg.tar.zst

[JGG-Apps]

Hi,

Even if I try to use X11 or KMS, after boot I always get a black screen but I heard soound like the Attract-Mode is running.

I verified and mesa package is OK... I resintalled many many time. Format HDD, reinstall on many different computers, I have over 20 units of this model ;)

But, I found something that could put you on the touch:

After booting, when I heard sound and a black screen, I go trough any other console (TTY2 or higher). I can see the login prompt perfectly (in 15 khz, LCD or any mode depending of my test scenario). When the login prompt is visible, I don't need to open a session. If I just press the ENTER key... this will do something (I don't know why) but I see the mouse cursor for few milliseconds and the MAME console appears on the screen and I'm OK !!!

Then, I just realize that everything I did on any TTY2 or more console, the ENTER button is what is fixing the issue. It's weird, but it's like the ENTER button still linked with all consoles to force something to keep alive the MAME console ?!

Remember, it's something happen with version 2022.10 only and Intel VGA Onboard video card.

To find the problem, I would like to determine at whiche level exactly this happen. Could you help me to make a tweak ? Could you tell me what I need to set in GroovyArcade OS 2022.10 to don't load anything at boot time... Just boot on a Linux console ?

The goal is to determine if the issue is caused by KMS or by something loaded after.

[substring]

I'd need the output of a few commands:

for p in /sys/class/drm/card? ; do
  id=$(basename `readlink -f $p/device`)
  name=$(lspci -mms $id | cut -d '"' -f4,6 --output-delimiter=" ")
  cardnum=$(basename $p)
  module_name=$(lspci -ks $id | grep "Kernel driver in use:" | cut -d ":" -f 2 |tr -d ' ')
  echo "$cardnum ($module_name): $name"
  for p in /sys/class/drm/${cardnum}-*/status; do
    con=${p%/status}
    bus=$(ls -d "$con"/i2c-* 2>/dev/null)
    echo -n "  ${con#*/card?-}: $(cat $p)"
    [[ -n $bus ]] && echo -n " - Has i2c"
    edid_size=$(cat "$con"/edid | wc -c)
    if [[ $edid_size > 0 ]] ; then
      echo -n " - Found an EDID with monitor model: "
      edid-decode < "$con"/edid |grep "Display Product Name: " | sed "s/Display Product Name\: //"
    fi
    echo -e "\nList of video modes:"
    cat "$con"/modes
  done
done

And as root, when AM is running on KMS:

grep -E '^'$'\t''(allocated|size)' /sys/kernel/debug/dri/0/framebuffer

Your symptoms are like someone who has 2 GPUs. Remember that for X you must update your OS or it won't work.

To boot to a console, just disable the startefe.sh script in ~/.bash_profile. GA is meant to autologin on tty1, disable the service eventually