2fa stopped working after upgrade to symfony 5.2 about 2fa

[scheb]

v5.2.1 released to fix issues related to lazy firewalls.

[PhilETaylor]

It was all working in Symfony 5.2 until I upgraded to 5.2 of this bundle - now Im trying to get my head around what has broken ... currently at the error:

with two-factor-auth via google authenticator:

The two-factor provider "totp" has not been prepared.

[dirkkredler]

The Bundle Version 5.2.0 works for me with Symfony 5.1.9; in my case i think the breaking change is introduced with Symfony 5.2 or the combination of both: Symfony 5.2.0 with the Bundle 5.2.0? I do not see any error messages at all in the logs; it seems the 2fa-token is just not generated.

[PhilETaylor]

Im using 5.2.0/5.2.0 and I was able to generate a qr - scan it - but now not able to login with generic "An authentication exception occurred."... im debugging now :(

[scheb]

Well that's odd. When running my test application, In not having that issue. So we'd need to find out what's special about your application and causing the issue.

@dirkkredler
Which security system are you using? Classic security or the new authenticators system?

Would you please:

• Post your security.yaml config
• Downgrade The bundle to 5.1.4 and keep Symfony at 5.2.0 and see if you're still having issues. That way we can check if the behavioral change is caused by Symfony or the bundle.

[PhilETaylor]

Also of note: I run PHP 8 ;-)

[dirkkredler]

Which security system are you using? Classic security or the new authenticators system?

I am using the guard-based authentication

• Post your security.yaml config

security.yaml and scheb_two_factor config

• Downgrade Thebundle to 5.1.4 and keep Symfony at 5.2.0 and see if you're still having issues. That way we can check if the behavioral change is caused by Symfony or the bundle.

Done, 2fa still broken in my setup.

thank you very much for your time and help, and the bundle of course 👍

[scheb]

I notice there is no pattern defined for your main firewall. @PhilETaylor just told me in the other thread, that adding pattern: / was fixing it for him. So I'd suggest you try that before we dig any deeper.

[dirkkredler]

Yeah, i don't think we need it here, but anyway, i added the pattern to the main firewall, cleared the cache and it stays the same. If i select the user in the database, i see that there is no token generated.

You can postpone this issue for now, i will look into this later this week and try to debug the issue to a deeper level, so i can provide you more information. At the moment i don't see any BC in Symfony 5.2.0 or changes that would affect my app.

[PhilETaylor]

lazy! #39 ?

[dirkkredler]

@PhilETaylor yeah, setting lazy: false fixes the issue 👍

[dirkkredler]

please see #39