Android Broken dependency to "com.google.firebase:firebase-messaging:$firebase_messaging_version" about unity-sdk

[OliverRiisager]

@suriksarkisyan no, but we use R8 in ours. And we also have custom proguard file enabled - though it is empty at the moment.

As promised - here are our settings :

Dependencies :
    "com.google.external-dependency-manager": "file:../Firebase/firebase-unity-packages/com.google.external-dependency-manager-1.2.166.tgz",
    "com.google.firebase.app": "file:../Firebase/firebase-unity-packages/com.google.firebase.app-8.1.0.tgz",
    "com.google.firebase.auth": "file:../Firebase/firebase-unity-packages/com.google.firebase.auth-8.1.0.tgz",
    "com.google.firebase.firestore": "file:../Firebase/firebase-unity-packages/com.google.firebase.firestore-8.1.0.tgz",
    "com.google.firebase.functions": "file:../Firebase/firebase-unity-packages/com.google.firebase.functions-8.1.0.tgz",
	
	Package install guide : 
		Due to this issue we can not use package manager in the normal way for Firebase: 
		https://github.com/firebase/quickstart-unity/issues/1030

		Update firebase by following these instructions:
		https://firebase.google.com/docs/unity/setup-alternative?hl=ca#alternative_unity_package_manager

		Using this download achieve:
		https://developers.google.com/unity/archive?hl=ca

		Drop the files in Firebase/firebase-unity-packages
		Update Packages/manifest.json to local paths
		
GvhProjectSettings:
	<projectSettings>
		<projectSetting name="com.google.external-dependency-managerAnalyticsEnabled" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="com.google.firebaseAnalyticsEnabled" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.IOSResolver.AutoPodToolInstallInEditor" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.IOSResolver.CocoapodsIntegrationMethod" value="2"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.IOSResolver.PodfileAddUseFrameworks" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.IOSResolver.PodfileAllowPodsInMultipleTargets" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.IOSResolver.PodfileAlwaysAddMainTarget" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.IOSResolver.PodfileEnabled" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.IOSResolver.PodfileStaticLinkFrameworks" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.IOSResolver.PodToolExecutionViaShellEnabled" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.IOSResolver.VerboseLoggingEnabled" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.PackageManagerResolver.Enable" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.PackageManagerResolver.PromptToAddRegistries" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.PackageManagerResolver.PromptToMigratePackages" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.PackageManagerResolver.VerboseLoggingEnabled" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="Google.VersionHandler.VerboseLoggingEnabled" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.AndroidPackageInstallationEnabled" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.AutoResolutionDisabledWarning" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.AutoResolveOnBuild" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.AutoResolverEnabled" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.ExplodeAars" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.LocalMavenRepoDir" value="Assets/GeneratedLocalRepo"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.PatchAndroidManifest" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.PatchMainTemplateGradle" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.PatchPropertiesTemplateGradle" value="True"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.PromptBeforeAutoResolution" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.UseGradleDaemon" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.UseJetifier" value="False"/>
		<projectSetting name="GooglePlayServices.VerboseLogging" value="False"/>
	</projectSettings>

AndroidResolvedDependencies.xml:
	<dependencies>
		<packages>
			<package>com.fasterxml.jackson.core:jackson-databind:2.11.1</package>
			<package>com.google.android.gms:play-services-base:17.6.0</package>
			<package>com.google.firebase:firebase-analytics:19.0.0</package>
			<package>com.google.firebase:firebase-app-unity:8.1.0</package>
			<package>com.google.firebase:firebase-auth:21.0.1</package>
			<package>com.google.firebase:firebase-auth-unity:8.1.0</package>
			<package>com.google.firebase:firebase-common:20.0.0</package>
			<package>com.google.firebase:firebase-firestore:23.0.1</package>
			<package>com.google.firebase:firebase-firestore-unity:8.1.0</package>
			<package>com.google.firebase:firebase-functions:20.0.0</package>
			<package>com.google.firebase:firebase-functions-unity:8.1.0</package>
			<package>io.qonversion.android.sdk:sdk:3.2.4</package>
			<package>org.jetbrains.kotlin:kotlin-stdlib-jdk7:1.2.61</package>
		</packages>
		<files>
			<file>Assets/GeneratedLocalRepo/Firebase/m2repository/com/google/firebase/firebase-app-unity/8.1.0/firebase-app-unity-8.1.0.aar</file>
			<file>Assets/GeneratedLocalRepo/Firebase/m2repository/com/google/firebase/firebase-app-unity/8.1.0/firebase-app-unity-8.1.0.pom</file>
			<file>Assets/GeneratedLocalRepo/Firebase/m2repository/com/google/firebase/firebase-auth-unity/8.1.0/firebase-auth-unity-8.1.0.aar</file>
			<file>Assets/GeneratedLocalRepo/Firebase/m2repository/com/google/firebase/firebase-auth-unity/8.1.0/firebase-auth-unity-8.1.0.pom</file>
			<file>Assets/GeneratedLocalRepo/Firebase/m2repository/com/google/firebase/firebase-firestore-unity/8.1.0/firebase-firestore-unity-8.1.0.aar</file>
			<file>Assets/GeneratedLocalRepo/Firebase/m2repository/com/google/firebase/firebase-firestore-unity/8.1.0/firebase-firestore-unity-8.1.0.pom</file>
			<file>Assets/GeneratedLocalRepo/Firebase/m2repository/com/google/firebase/firebase-functions-unity/8.1.0/firebase-functions-unity-8.1.0.aar</file>
			<file>Assets/GeneratedLocalRepo/Firebase/m2repository/com/google/firebase/firebase-functions-unity/8.1.0/firebase-functions-unity-8.1.0.pom</file>
		</files>
		<settings>
			<setting name="androidAbis" value="arm64-v8a,armeabi-v7a"/>
			<setting name="bundleId" value="{bundleid}"/>
			<setting name="explodeAars" value="True"/>
			<setting name="gradleBuildEnabled" value="True"/>
			<setting name="gradlePropertiesTemplateEnabled" value="True"/>
			<setting name="gradleTemplateEnabled" value="True"/>
			<setting name="installAndroidPackages" value="True"/>
			<setting name="localMavenRepoDir" value="Assets/GeneratedLocalRepo"/>
			<setting name="packageDir" value="Assets/Plugins/Android"/>
			<setting name="patchAndroidManifest" value="True"/>
			<setting name="patchMainTemplateGradle" value="True"/>
			<setting name="projectExportEnabled" value="True"/>
			<setting name="useJetifier" value="False"/>
		</settings>
	</dependencies>

[suriksarkisyan]

Hi, @OliverRiisager
Thanks for the solution. You are right, and the problem is related to the firebase messaging. And, of course, we tested that before the release. The strange thing is I can't reproduce that error on my device. I unsuccessfully tried to reproduce that issue in an empty project a few times. Anyway, I'll continue investigating the problem, and we will fix it in the following versions.
Thank you again 🙏

[OliverRiisager]

I will send you a list of the dependencies and packages we use in our project. We also use some firebase packages (but not messaging). As well as our gvhprojectsettings file. So you can apply that to your test project.

…

On Mon, May 9, 2022, 20:40 Surik Sarkisyan ***@***.***> wrote: Hi, @OliverRiisager <https://github.com/OliverRiisager> Thanks for the solution. You are right, and the problem is related to the firebase messaging. And, of course, we tested that before the release. The strange thing is I can't reproduce that error on my device. I unsuccessfully tried to reproduce that issue in an empty project a few times. Anyway, I'll continue investigating the problem, and we will fix it in the following versions. Thank you again 🙏 — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#77 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AO47WTRL5BCJHS4GHEKN373VJFLYLANCNFSM5VPDFXNA> . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[suriksarkisyan]

Deal! Thank you so much for the help!

[OliverRiisager]

Have you tried exporting the project instead of building it? If you go to build settings and enable export (on Android target). Then export the project, open it in android studio and built in there. Then you should see the error i would think

…

On Mon, May 9, 2022, 20:44 Surik Sarkisyan ***@***.***> wrote: Deal! Thank you so much for the help! — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#77 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AO47WTVHMEOZEOC4S2FPNBTVJFMKNANCNFSM5VPDFXNA> . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[suriksarkisyan]

Yes, I tried. And there wasn't an error. I'll try a few more ways and let you know.

[OliverRiisager]

Hmm, alright. Do you have minification enabled for release and debug? Also we have R8 turned on, because otherwise your Moshi plugin fails compiling due to the proguard version unity uses (in our version) with some generics stuff. We use 2020.3.27f1

…

On Mon, May 9, 2022, 21:04 Surik Sarkisyan ***@***.***> wrote: Yes, I tried. And there wasn't an error. I'll try a few more ways and let you know. — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#77 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AO47WTT36COT3UYCPGSKPZTVJFOTTANCNFSM5VPDFXNA> . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[suriksarkisyan]

No, we don't use ProGuard or R8 in our SDK.

[OliverRiisager]

btw you have to change this to be your own bundle id. setting name="bundleId" value="{bundleid}"

[pixelfoxxx]

Hello @OliverRiisager! We've researched everything and understand the problem, but we cannot reproduce it locally. The temporal fix is like the one you posted in the above messages. By the way, we will fix this issue in future releases. Thank you for your report and help in determining this issue!

Let us know if you have any further questions. We'll be glad to assist!

[OliverRiisager]

Just wanted to point out, that it works now after updating to 4.0.1. I see you restructured the packages/changed your import statements around - which I'm guessing is the reason that it is now working. That still doesn't change the fact that it doesn't work for your previous implementations - in case users still want to use that version for whatever reason I suggest letting this fix live in a doc somewhere for them to use.

[SpertsyanKM]

Sorry for not getting back to you sooner, somehow we've lost this issue. Yes, you are right. The original problem was fixed from version 4.0.0 as we removed the firebase-messaging dependency, so the best solution would be to migrate to the latest SDK version.

Those, who don't want to migrate right now, can consider the solution from the author's start message.

We will consider adding a suggested workaround to our documentation. I'm closing this issue as the problem is fixed in the latest SDK versions. Thank you for your report and feel free to contact us if you have any further questions!