is v3 ESM only? about formidable

[GrosSacASac]

Published [email protected]

[GrosSacASac]

Did you read the changelog ?

[hannesfant]

Yes

formidable/CHANGELOG.md

Line 80 in 0179abf

* feat: Use ES modules ([#727](https://github.com/node-formidable/formidable/pull/727))

I think @GrosSacASac could have said it immediately instead, since it's quite buried in the changelog, and most users don't read it to begin with. Just answering the question immediately would save everyone a lot of time, but that's just my opinion :)

[phpbg]

Hi,

yes, I did read the changelog, but AFAIK the fact that you internally use ESM does not imply that you don't built with commonJS support (sorry i'am not sure about it).

At least I would say it is not quite obvious, and it is not a feature, but a breaking change...

[GrosSacASac]

Is it a good idea to make it work both with commonjs and esmodules ?

[phpbg]

Is it a good idea to make it work both with commonjs and esmodules ?

Well, it depends on your v2 vs v3 strategy.

If you want to promote v3 for everyone, I suggest you make it work for both.

Anyway it would be great to make a clear statement in your readme

[GrosSacASac]

#944

[phpbg]

Thank you!

I guess I have to move on 3.5+ now ;-)