Critical bug in source generated components about mudblazor

[ScarletKuro]

Hi,

I think the title and description are misleading. MudBlazor doesn't own or control the source generator for components. It is controlled by Microsoft's Razor internal source generator, which is located in this repository: https://github.com/dotnet/razor.

I'll repeat myself: the screenshot provided here #9052 (comment) is not something that MudBlazor generates.

In this comment, you claim #9052 (comment) "now also is not working on 6.12.0". If it was working before but suddenly stopped, then it means there is a regression in the Razor source generator. This is not uncommon, as I reported one of the biggest regressions last year: dotnet/razor#8718 and others SDK 6 dotnet/razor#8770 that won't be fixed.

If you believe it was something that was working before in an earlier version of VS, SDK, or suddenly stopped working on the library version that worked before, then this is the wrong repository to report such issues, as we can't help here.

If you think we misunderstood something and it was a change in the MudBlazor code affecting how the component ID is formed and passed:

MudBlazor/src/MudBlazor/Components/CheckBox/MudCheckBox.razor.cs

Line 18 in f3dccfe

private string _elementId = "checkbox" + Guid.NewGuid().ToString().Substring(0, 8);

Then you need to provide more input on what and where the change occurred. I don't recall any changes in this direction, and it sounds suspicious to claim that 6.12.0 worked and then suddenly stopped. This is not something we could influence.

[FritzTheCat9]

@ScarletKuro From my point of view when i was debugging my application i didn't get any errors. Now im getting errors (i updated Visual Studio 2022 preview version and also updated nuget pacages and MudBlazor) so i was thinking that it was related to updating my nuget packages or visual studio. I did not change the code in places from where im getting errors about missing element with certain id. I will try to find .NET SDK version that worked before update. Thanks for reply.