Thank you about beep

[rhonda]

<3 Thanks for sharing! I'll leave it open for a bit for a purpose. :)

[federico-razzoli]

Can I ask which kernel limitations affect beep?

@rhonda Alright :)

@Santec I was referring those you talked about in the README, in particular, concerning the availability of beep outside of the TTY (in a terminal emulator in X11).

There are also frequencies mismatches when they are high: beep -f 1500 and beep -f 1350 produce the same sound. I assumed this was also a known limitation.

And not being possible to compose two beep sound at the same time, but implementing a sound library inside the beep command would be an overkill right ? ;)

[federico-razzoli]

I didn't write the README, I am just a curious reader :)
Thanks for answering.
I'm also curious about the "2 beeps" thing. Is the bell hardware able to emit more than 1 sound at a time?

[ndim]

For the record: On my system, beep -f 1500 and beep -f 1350 do produce differently pitched sounds. This behaviour differs from the one @josuah describes above. (My system is running Fedora 24, and I maintain the beep package on Fedora, but not the kernel drivers.)

[hyh19962008]

I think you can have multiple speakers installed if you want to have more sound at the same time!

[ndim]

The circuits for the PC beep exists only once per PC chipset. So to have more than one tone at the same time you need more than one PC.