How to remove all unnecessary data about nimpng

[AmjadHD]

I think it's not related to compression.
When opening the 3 images in https://www.nayuki.io/page/png-file-chunk-inspector, it shows that gimp only includes IHDR, IDAT and IEND chunks.
while nimPNG also includes PLTE and tRNS

[jangko]

I assume your pngs contain transparency and no animation frames, therefore I use loadPNG32/savePNG32 pair.

what we do here basically only preserve the pixel data(+ transparency) and discard everything else.
if you also want to discard transparency, you can use loadPNG24/savePNG24 version.

And then nimPNG will try to find the best compression for your new png.

let lres = loadPNG32(seq[uint8], "input.png")
if lres.isOk:
  let png = lres.get()
  let sres = savePNG32("output.png", png.data, png.width, png.height)      
  if sres.isErr:
    echo sres.error
else:
  echo lres.error

[AmjadHD]

Hi, Thanks for your help !
That still produces larger output than gimp
Original: 157B
GIMP: 103B
nimPNG: 134B

[jangko]

then try this. it will take longer time, but produce smaller output.
if it still produce larger size than gimp, then you perhaps should find other png library.
currently nimPNG doesn't expose it's compression library settings to user, and it requires some work to enable that. and unfortunately I'm still too busy to make such modification.

var conf = makePNGEncoder()
conf.filterStrategy = LFS_BRUTE_FORCE

let sres = savePNG32("output.png", png.data, png.width, png.height, conf) 

[jangko]

I see, then you can try to turn off autoConvert. If autoConvert enabled, it will count how many colors in the image and create palette if color number <= 256. This strategy works for bigger image to reduce file size. But looks like your image is small enough and this feature actually add more bytes.

var conf = makePNGEncoder()
conf.autoConvert = false

[jangko]

alternative, read important chunk only, and then write back without reencoding.

import ../nimPNG, streams

proc main() =
  var conf = makePNGDecoder()
  conf.colorConvert = false
  conf.readTextChunks = false
  conf.rememberUnknownChunks = false
  
  var s = newFileStream("input.png", fmRead)
  var png = decodePNG(seq[uint8], s, conf)
  s.close()
    
  s = newFileStream("output.png", fmWrite)
  png.writeChunks s
  s.close()
  
main()

[AmjadHD]

The first code produces 111B (better), gimp produces 103B.
The second one produces a corrupt file.

[jangko]

sorry, out of idea.