Checking hasUpdate() should not require is_writable for phar file. about phar-updater

[jxn]

This comes up often for me with scripts which are globally installed.

For instance, we deploy a phar automatically to /usr/bin/myscript which is used by users across the system. Most of the users use the phar, but only one should be allowed to update it. In the event of a failure when an unprivileged user uses the phar, she should be able to see if the phar is up to date, and request that the administrator update it.

Ideally, we would be able to institute a check when users run other commands, which would use phar-updater to check if the latest version is in use. Then, when a user ran myscript some:command, they would be warned that "myscript" is not up-to-date. Currently, that would throw an error and prevent all unprivileged users from running any command.

Additionally, we have scripts that do integrity checks on systems. These scripts should not be able to write to the system, but it would be nice if they could check if globally-installed phar files are up-to-date and report that to system administrators.

[aik099]

What would be a use case for this?

[jxn]

I have added this in PR #21

[aik099]

In the event of a failure when an unprivileged user uses the phar, she should be able to see if the phar is up to date, and request that the administrator update it.

That's what I imagined myself. But on the other hand isn't it's administrator job to ensure all stuff is up to date and not forward that task on regular user 😄

Then, when a user ran myscript some:command, they would be warned that "myscript" is not up-to-date. Currently, that would throw an error and prevent all unprivileged users from running any command.

I'd like that, but again this could be an option because displaying your app is out of date message to user that can't really update it adds more confusion. In your case I admit it can be useful.

Can you please also attach an exception trace?

[padraic]

I've been AWOL for a while, but I'll doing a round of PR reviews eventually. I see no harm in this change myself if it's useful.

[tschach]

Hi,
what is the status of this? I came across the issue using a third-party application that includes phar-updater. If someone could give me some pointers, I would be willing to help solving this issue.
Best, Tobias