Rework and unify the flow for using weapons, items, and spells. about dcc

[cyface]

@mooped is it possible to make a setting to auto roll the damage and crits as it does now? 🤔

[mooped]

@mooped is it possible to make a setting to auto roll the damage and crits as it does now? 🤔

My thought on that was that the 'Use Standard Chat Cards' option should probably go away (it creates a lot of complexity) and a new option to automatically proceed through the flow would come in (might even make it default), but importantly there would be only one version of each step in the attack flow and the option just determines whether the next stage triggers automatically or not.

We'd lose the current combined chat card for the entire roll, though. I'm not sure how attached to it you are?

I personally like it for its simplicity, but it seems that lots of people want functionality that is incompatible with it so I'm not sure it's worth the complexity of keeping that aspect of the feature around as an option.

If we add hooks at the end of each step of the flow it becomes very easy for external modules to provide additional automation and customisation. For example a module can listen for the dcc.attackRoll hook and make a decision to trigger the next step based on the selected target (or whatever other information they want to use).

[mooped]

I think crits would always automatically trigger as part of the attack roll process, and could be combined into the attack roll card, it's only really rolling damage that is contentious since it's dependent on the target.

[cyface]

Especially for NPCs, I'd really prefer some way for us not to have more than one click per attack. I'm not at all attached to how it looks in the chat. 👍🏻

[mooped]

You're right, as a judge it would really annoy me to have to make the extra click to get the damage amount.

I think the feedback can be broken down into a few issues:

• Players seeing their damage before they decide to spend luck on the to hit roll
• Judges wanting to fast roll NPC attacks
• Judges wanting to automate checking for hits/range etc
• Handling special weapons that don't deal damage
• Applying the target's luck to crits
• Automating luck spend on attacks/deeds/damage
• Probably more I've forgotten right now

I will have a rethink of how the setting should work, I'm starting to think there should be a setting for the judge and one for the players. Having a client side setting might please some people, but the issue of seeing the damage before spending luck comes back in.

For the chat card I think it might be nice to see if we can collate any rolls made automatically in one card. That allows the extra functionality and optional automation while avoiding some clutter, and would hopefully solve the annoying issue of Foundry playing several overlapping roll sounds with the current separate chat cards flow.

We might need to look at what if any modules rely on the separate chat cards setting too.