Determine solution or official recommendation for autofill issues about hideshowpassword

[tylersticka]

Ah, the dreaded browser autofill. This shouldn't have anything to do with the plugin, but with the behavior of the username/password fields on your page. (If you were to remove the plugin but keep the <input> elements, I'd bet you'd still see them auto-filled.)

In a future version of the plugin, I'd like to have some sort of "recommended" option for dealing with this. Currently, there's no magic solution.

One thing you can do is try disabling the browser autofill on the <input> elements themselves. I recommend this Mozilla article for doing that.

You can also just hide the password by default. If that's not your style, you could defer enabling that field until you're sure it isn't autofilled... though that can be complicated. There are many techniques for doing so and even an autofill event plugin.

We'll be exploring this further in the future. In the meantime, if you stumble upon a combination of solutions that work for you, please let us know so we can incorporate that knowledge into the plugin.

[javayoung]

Oh, thank you for your quick and elaborate reply. 👍

I see your point about the autofill issue. I will also think over how to counter it based on your idea and will let you know. Meanwhile, i will keep watching your github. :0) Thank you so much for your reply.

[simevidas]

I think the ideal implementation of the “Show password” feature would be as follows:

1. the control is initially disabled (HTML disabled attribute)
2. when the user edits the password field for the first time, confirm the the current value has been produced from user input (i.e. it wasn’t autofilled), and only then enable the control

You can see this functionality in practice here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dt8np9kYCVM

@tylersticka Please consider adding this as an option.

[tylersticka]

Thanks, @simevidas! Regarding this portion:

when the user edits the password field for the first time, confirm the the current value has been produced from user input (i.e. it wasn’t autofilled)

Any advice on how one would reliably do that?