Manual toggling about windows-auto-night-mode

[Spiritreader]

Instead, my desired solution is that once I toggle to dark mode, it will only auto-toggle it back to light mode at 7 am

That is precisely what happens.

Your configured sunset is at 15:50, and automatic theme switching will resume after that time.

Having automatic switching enabled before 15:50 would switch you back to light mode, as at that point it's considered day.
Having automatic switching enabled after 15:50 would switch you to dark mode (if you aren't already in dark mode)
Since you're already in dark mode because you toggled the theme at 3pm and postponed the automatic switching until 15:50, ADM will stay in dark mode after 15:50 (as is the normal behavior) because at that point the system time has advanced to a point where the dark schedule becomes active.

[github-actions]

No updates have been provided to this issue after 60 days of inactivity. The issue will be automatically closed in 7 days.