Data binning segfaults when data is in device memory on non-unified memory systems about ascent

[nicolemarsaglia]

Thanks for the info! I'm a tad sick so I'm taking the rest of the day (sorry!), but I can get back to this on Monday.

[cyrush]

Thanks for confirming this behavior, we will work to resolve these limits for binning.

[nicolemarsaglia]

Hey @BenWibking sorry for the delay.

A reproducer would be great and I can do my best to try to help you figure out this issue!

[BenWibking]

Thanks. I've put a reproducer here: parthenon-hpc-lab/athenapk#49. Let me know what you find.

[BenWibking]

@nicolemarsaglia I've rebuilt Ascent + TPLs with debugging info and I get a more informative backtrace. The segmentation fault happens here:

(cuda-gdb) bt
#0  ascent::runtime::expressions::binning (dataset=..., bin_axes=..., reduction_var="Density", reduction_op="avg", empty_bin_val=0,
    component="") at /projects/cvz/bwibking/ascent_debug/ascent/src/libs/ascent/runtimes/expressions/ascent_blueprint_architect.cpp:1649
#1  0x00007fb75d836285 in ascent::runtime::expressions::binning_interface (reduction_var="Density", reduction_op="avg",
    n_empty_bin_val=..., n_component=..., n_axis_list=..., dataset=..., n_binning=..., n_output_axes=...)
    at /projects/cvz/bwibking/ascent_debug/ascent/src/libs/ascent/runtimes/expressions/ascent_expression_filters.cpp:3158
#2  0x00007fb75d836c1a in ascent::runtime::expressions::Binning::execute (this=0xc40cdc0)
    at /projects/cvz/bwibking/ascent_debug/ascent/src/libs/ascent/runtimes/expressions/ascent_expression_filters.cpp:3197
#3  0x00007fb75d0b9ba9 in flow::Workspace::execute (this=0x7ffd1f630098)
    at /projects/cvz/bwibking/ascent_debug/ascent/src/libs/flow/flow_workspace.cpp:303
#4  0x00007fb75d7423a7 in ascent::runtime::expressions::ExpressionEval::evaluate (this=0x7ffd1f630030,
    expr="binning('Density','avg', [axis('x',[-0.5,0.5]), axis('y', [-0.5,0.5]), axis('z', num_bins=64)])",
    expr_name="avg_density_profile")
    at /projects/cvz/bwibking/ascent_debug/ascent/src/libs/ascent/runtimes/ascent_expression_eval.cpp:1534
#5  0x00007fb75d927c35 in ascent::runtime::filters::BasicQuery::execute (this=0xa08c460)
    at /projects/cvz/bwibking/ascent_debug/ascent/src/libs/ascent/runtimes/flow_filters/ascent_runtime_query_filters.cpp:127
#6  0x00007fb75d0b9ba9 in flow::Workspace::execute (this=0x7df7460)
    at /projects/cvz/bwibking/ascent_debug/ascent/src/libs/flow/flow_workspace.cpp:303
#7  0x00007fb75d6fba4f in ascent::AscentRuntime::Execute (this=0x7df6ec0, actions=...)
    at /projects/cvz/bwibking/ascent_debug/ascent/src/libs/ascent/runtimes/ascent_main_runtime.cpp:1831
#8  0x00007fb75d6e1915 in ascent::Ascent::execute (this=0x7ffd1f6318d0, actions=...)
    at /projects/cvz/bwibking/ascent_debug/ascent/src/libs/ascent/ascent.cpp:410
#9  0x000000000085ba78 in parthenon::AscentOutput::WriteOutputFile(parthenon::Mesh*, parthenon::ParameterInput*, parthenon::SimTime*, parthenon::SignalHandler::OutputSignal) ()
#10 0x0000000000777e7e in parthenon::Outputs::MakeOutputs(parthenon::Mesh*, parthenon::ParameterInput*, parthenon::SimTime*, parthenon::SignalHandler::OutputSignal) ()
#11 0x00000000006cfcb1 in parthenon::EvolutionDriver::Execute() ()
#12 0x00000000004419df in main ()
(cuda-gdb) list
1644	//#endif
1645	        for(int i = 0; i < homes_size; ++i)
1646	        {
1647	          if(homes[i] != -1)
1648	          {
1649	            update_bin(bins, homes[i], values[i], reduction_op);
1650	          }
1651	        }
1652	      }
1653	    }

[BenWibking]

Here's info args:

(cuda-gdb) info args
dataset = @0xc2bec10: {m_parent = 0x0, m_schema = 0xc2bfb20, m_owns_schema = true,
  m_children = std::vector of length 44, capacity 64 = {0xc309760, 0xc2bd670, 0xc2bd710, 0xc30a490, 0xc30a270, 0xc2bf2b0, 0xc2bf430,
    0xc2c1530, 0xc30feb0, 0xc2c4f60, 0xc2c5f20, 0xc2c2130, 0xc2c5ca0, 0xc2c91c0, 0xc2c9d10, 0xc2c8f90, 0xc2c25e0, 0xc2cbba0, 0xc2cbd10,
    0xc2c4bb0, 0xc2ccc90, 0xc2c2c10, 0xc2c7590, 0xc2cabe0, 0xc2c7380, 0xc2d51b0, 0xc2d4000, 0xc2d7020, 0xc355040, 0xc2d8e00, 0xa10ea60,
    0xc2dab80, 0xc2d4e00, 0xc2da950, 0xb841190, 0xc2db6e0, 0xc2de550, 0xc2d8930, 0xc2d5ea0, 0xc2e17a0, 0xc2e25d0, 0xc3d98b0, 0xc2e42f0,
    0xc2e5290}, m_data = 0x0, m_data_size = 0, m_alloced = false, m_mmaped = false, m_mmap = 0x0, m_allocator_id = 0}
bin_axes = @0x7ffd1f62ea80: {m_parent = 0x0, m_schema = 0xc413880, m_owns_schema = true,
  m_children = std::vector of length 3, capacity 4 = {0xc40fb70, 0xc40f570, 0xc40fa70}, m_data = 0x0, m_data_size = 0,
  m_alloced = false, m_mmaped = false, m_mmap = 0x0, m_allocator_id = 0}
reduction_var = "Density"
reduction_op = "avg"
empty_bin_val = 0
component = ""

And info locals:

(cuda-gdb) info locals
i = 26
values = {m_data = 0x7fb6ee6f9280, m_dtype = {m_id = 12, m_num_ele = 1728, m_offset = 0, m_stride = 8, m_ele_bytes = 8,
    m_endianness = 0}}
comp_path = ""
values_path = "fields/Density/values"
dom = @0xc309760: {m_parent = 0xc2bec10, m_schema = 0xc3096f0, m_owns_schema = false,
  m_children = std::vector of length 4, capacity 4 = {0xc309910, 0xc30a720, 0xc30ada0, 0xc30c280}, m_data = 0x0, m_data_size = 0,
  m_alloced = false, m_mmaped = false, m_mmap = 0x0, m_allocator_id = 0}
n_homes = {m_parent = 0x0, m_schema = 0xc413bc0, m_owns_schema = true, m_children = std::vector of length 0, capacity 0,
  m_data = 0xc4141f0, m_data_size = 6912, m_alloced = true, m_mmaped = false, m_mmap = 0x0, m_allocator_id = 0}
homes = 0xc4141f0
homes_size = 1728
dom_index = 0
var_names = std::vector of length 4, capacity 6 = {"x", "y", "z", "Density"}
topo_and_assoc = @0x7ffd1f62d800: {m_parent = 0x0, m_schema = 0xc411040, m_owns_schema = true,
  m_children = std::vector of length 2, capacity 2 = {0xc2cc2e0, 0xc410de0}, m_data = 0x0, m_data_size = 0, m_alloced = false,
  m_mmaped = false, m_mmap = 0x0, m_allocator_id = 0}
topo_name = "topo"
assoc_str = "element"
bounds = @0x7ffd1f62d760: {m_parent = 0x0, m_schema = 0xc4112a0, m_owns_schema = true,
  m_children = std::vector of length 2, capacity 2 = {0xc410fe0, 0xc413820}, m_data = 0x0, m_data_size = 0, m_alloced = false,
  m_mmaped = false, m_mmap = 0x0, m_allocator_id = 0}
min_coords = 0xc2c4370
max_coords = 0xc2c0b20
axes = {{"x", "i", "dx"}, {"y", "j", "dy"}, {"z", "k", "dz"}}
num_axes = 3
num_bins = 64
num_bin_vars = 2
bins_size = 128
bins = 0x6e99a90
mpi_comm = 0x7ffd1f62e240
global_bins = 0x10000000c2bec10
res = {m_parent = 0x0, m_schema = 0xc413880, m_owns_schema = false,
  m_children = std::vector of length -17553172076876, capacity -17553146376764 = {0x458b48c389481aeb, 0xf528ede8c78948e8,
    0xe8c78948d88948ff, 0xf85d8b48fff59272, 0x4853e5894855c3c9, 0x48e87d894818ec83, 0x48e8458b48e07589, 0x48fff4b0ffe8c789,
    0x53e8c78948e8458b, 0x48e0558b48fff4a6, 0x8948d68948e8458b, 0x1aebfff58e20e8c7, 0x48e8458b48c38948, 0x48fff5288fe8c789,
    0x9214e8c78948d889, 0xc3c9f85d8b48fff5, 0xec834853e5894855, 0x758948e87d894818, 0xc78948e8458b48e0, 0x458b48fff4b0a1e8,
    0xf4a5f5e8c78948e8, 0x458b48e0558b48ff, 0xe8c78948d68948e8, 0x89481aebfff49e32, 0xc78948e8458b48c3, 0xd88948fff52831e8,
    0xfff591b6e8c78948, 0x4855c3c9f85d8b48, 0x4848ec834853e589, 0x48b0758948b87d89, 0x43e8c78948b8458b, 0x48b8458b48fff4b0,
    0x48fff4a597e8c789, 0x1be8c78948ef458d, 0x48ef558d48fff592, 0x48c0458d48b04d8b, 0x4d94e8c78948ce89, 0x8b48c0558d48fff5,
    0xc78948d68948b845, 0x458d48fff49db1e8, 0xf4d5f5e8c78948c0, 0xc78948ef458d48ff, 0x483cebfff51dd9e8, 0x8948c0458d48c389,
    0x3ebfff4d5d8e8c7, 0x48ef458d48c38948, 0xebfff51db7e8c789, 0xb8458b48c3894803, 0xfff52776e8c78948, 0xfbe8c78948d88948,
    0xc9f85d8b48fff590, 0x8348e589485590c3, 0x8b48f87d894810ec, 0x5a9ce8c78948f845, 0x8948f8458b48fff5, 0xc990fff52740e8c7,
    0x8348e589485590c3, 0x8b48f87d894810ec, 0x5a74e8c78948f845, 0x485590c3c990fff5, 0xec8348535441e589, 0x758948b87d894840,
    0xc78948b8458b48b0, 0xef45c6fff483d1e8, 0xc78948b0458b4800, 0x458948fff4fe81e8, 0x5e7501d87d8348d8, 0xe8c78948b8458b48, 0x1ef45c6fff4ab0a, 0xe8c78948b0458b48, 0x48c38948fff4fb4a, 0xdbe8c78948b8458b, 0x8948de8948fff4bf, 0x8b48fff561a0e8c7, 0x94e4e8c78948b045, 0x458b48c38948fff5, 0xf48ae5e8c78948b8, 0xe8c78948de8948ff, 0x83482cebfff5196a, 0x458b48127502d87d, 0xf4a845e8c78948b8, 0x4813eb01ef45c6ff, 0x48b8458b48b0558b, 0x68bce8c78948d689, 0x840f00ef7d80fff5, 0xb8458b48000000af, 0xfff4d756e8c78948, 0xb0458b48d0458948, 0xfff4f0a6e8c78948, 0xe045c748c8458948, 0x8b4856eb00000000, 0x8948c8458b48e055, 0xf4cf75e8c78948d6, 0x40bf208b4cff, 0x8948fff51148e800, 0xe8df8948e6894cc3, 0xc05d8948fff5186a, 0xb8558b48c0458b48, 0xc0558d4838508948, 0x48d68948d0458b48, 0x48fff556b7e8c789, 0xc8458b4801e04583, 0xfff571e6e8c78948, 0x84c0920fe0453948, 0xc4894916eb9375c0, 0xfff50a0ee8df8948, 0x33e8c78948e0894c, 0x40c4834890fff58f, 0x485590c35d5c415b, 0x894810ec8348e589, 0x8b48f0758948f87d, 0x824ce8c78948f845, 0x8948f8458b48fff4, 0x8b48fff48530e8c7, 0x8948f0558b48f845, 0xf5518de8c78948d6, 0xe5894855c3c990ff, 0xf87d894810ec8348, 0xf8458b48f0758948, 0xfff4820ee8c78948, 0xe8c78948f0458b48, 0x1f88348fff4fcc2, 0x480e74c084c0940f, 0x4be8c78948f8458b, 0x458b4823ebfff4a9, 0xf4fc9de8c78948f0, 0xc0940f02f88348ff, 0xf8458b480c74c084, 0xfff4a6c6e8c78948, 0xf0558b48f8458b48, 0x43e8c78948d68948, 0x4855c3c990fff567, 0x894810ec8348e589, 0x8b48f0758948f87d, 0x8194e8c78948f845, 0x8b48f0558b48fff4, 0xc78948d68948f845, 0xc3c990fff4fe71e8, 0x10ec8348e5894855, 0xf0758948f87d8948, 0xf0453b48f8458b48, 0x8b48f0558b481374, 0xc78948d68948f845, 0x458b48fff4d771e8, 0xe589485590c3c9f8, 0xf87d894810ec8348, 0xf0558b48f0758948, 0x48d68948f8458b48, 0x48fff589d7e8c789, 0x485590c3c9f8458b, 0x894810ec8348e589, 0x8b48f0758948f87d, 0x8948f8458b48f055, 0xf49a1de8c78948d6, 0x90c3c9f8458b48ff, 0x40ec8348e5894855, 0xf845c748c87d8948, 0xc8458b4800000000, 0xfff4fb96e8c78948, 0xf07d8348f0458948, 0x2f07d8348077401, 0x8948c8458b487275, 0x8948fff4ee58e8c7, 0x8948e8458b48e845, 0x8948fff486d8e8c7, 0xd8458d4827ebd845, 0xfff54356e8c78948, 0x95e8c78948008b48, 0x48f8450148ffffff, 0x2be8c78948d8458d, 0x48e8458b48fff519, 0x48fff5754fe8c789, 0x48e0558d48e04589, 0x8948d68948d8458d, 0xc084fff55598e8c7, 0xf07d834817ebb275, 0x48c8458b48107400, 0x48fff573dfe8c789, 0xc9f8458b48f84589, 0x8348e589485590c3, 0xc748c87d894840ec, 0x8b4800000000f845, 0xfad4e8c78948c845, 0x8348f0458948fff4, 0x7d8348077401f07d, 0xc8458b48727502f0, 0xfff4ed96e8c78948, 0xe8458b48e8458948, 0xfff48616e8c78948, 0x8d4827ebd8458948, 0x4294e8c78948d845, 0xc78948008b48fff5, 0x450148ffffff95e8, 0xc78948d8458d48f8, 0x458b48fff51869e8, 0xf5748de8c78948e8, 0x558d48e0458948ff, 0xd68948d8458d48e0, 0xfff554d6e8c78948, 0x834817ebb275c084...}, m_data = 0x7ffd1f630130, m_data_size = 205600896, m_alloced = 48, m_mmaped = 234, m_mmap = 0x7fb754b039c7 <conduit::Node::init_defaults()+93>, m_allocator_id = 140725130029616}
res_bins = 0x26bbb40 <ompi_mpi_comm_world>

[BenWibking]

I've uploaded the core files here: https://cloudstor.aarnet.edu.au/plus/s/hTgYZQWYDYTPZn9

[BenWibking]

This is a very strange bug that I cannot reproduce on either Frontier or Summit. Somehow it appears to only happen on A100s.

[BenWibking]

Ok, I've traced the issue to the fact that the binning operation runs on the CPU and it attempts to dereference a device pointer, since our code sends the device-resident data to Ascent via zero-copy. This works on systems with unified memory, such as Summit and Frontier, but fails on systems without it.